Grayhaven Motel

The Property

A charming vintage motor lodge located in Ithaca, a small city in the beautiful Finger Lakes region of New York State. We offer 16 rooms year-round and one very cute 1964 Shasta camper during the summer months.


Located between Buttermilk Falls and Robert H. Treman State Parks, there are more area gorges and waterfalls than you can shake a stick at. The property is close to swimming, hiking, fishing, hunting and cross-country skiing.


  • Complimentary Parking

  • Dog Friendly

  • Flat Screen TV

  • Pet Friendly

Some History

Grayhaven is one of the oldest, and longest continually run hotels in Tompkins County. Property records go back to 1831 and include a string of farm land sales from 1850 to 1919. In 1952 the property was sold to R. Curtis and Jewel Gray whom purchased the property with the express intention of converting it to a motel; Soon after Grayhaven Motel was born.


Submit a Review

Send reply to a review

Send listing report

You already reported this listing

This is private and won't be shared with the owner.


Nearby Listings

No nearby listings were found



Sign in

Send Message

My favorites

Application Form

Claim Business


Skip to content